Like U.S. Master Limited Partnerships on Steroids: Higher Yields, USD Hedge
Part 10B of a Series
The High Dividend Investor’s Collapsing Dollar Survival Guide
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY FOR THIS SERIES
HIGH YIELD STOCKS ARE A FORM OF CASH. THUS INFLATION EATS AWAY AT BOTH YIELD AND PRINCIPLE. AS GOVERNMENTS INFLATE THEIR MONEY SUPPLY TO EASE CREDIT, MOST OBSERVERS BELIEVE INFLATION IS INEVITABLE.
THUS FAR IN THIS SERIES WE EXPLORED:
THE CURRENT STATE OF THE MARKET
THE CASE FOR AND AGAINST THE DOLLAR’S DEMISE
RECOMMENDED CRITERIA FOR SELECTING HIGH DIVIDEND STOCKS THAT ALSO GIVE A HEDGE AGAINST THE U.S. DOLLAR’S LIKELY IMPENDING DEPRECIATION.
SPECIFIC STOCK MARKET HEDGES AND HIGH DIVIDEND STOCKS THAT ARE INFLATION RESISTANT MENTIONED BELOW INCLUDE:
GENERAL MARKET HEDGES
UltraShort S & P 500 Proshares (SDS), UltraShort Financials ProShares (SKF), UltraShort QQQ ProShares (QID), UltraShort Real Estate ProShares (SRS), UltraShort Russell2000 ProShares (TWM)
INTERNATIONAL
Big Oil
BP, plc (BP), CNOOC Ltd. (CEO), Enid SpA (E), Total Fina Elf (TOT)
Utilities
Veolia Environmental SA (VE), ENEL-SOCIETA PER AZI (ESOCF.PK or ENLAY.PK)
Communications
Cellcom Israel Ltd. (CEL), France Telecom (FTE) Telefonica (TEF)
Shipping
Diana Shipping (DSX), Nordic American Tanker (NAT), Paragon Shipping (PRGN), Seaspan Corp (SSW)
Canadian Oil/Gas Energy Income Trusts
Advantage Energy Income Fund (AAV, TSX: AVN.UN), ARC Energy Trust (OTC: AETUF, TSX: AET-UN), Claymore/SWM Canadian Energy Income Fund (ENY), Enerplus Resources Fund (ERF), Peyto Energy Trust (OTC: PEYUF, TSX: PEY.UN), Provident Energy Trust (PVX, TSX: PVE.UN), Vermillion Energy Trust (OTC: VETMF, TSX: VET.UN)
Canadian Income Trust Tax Issues
IN PART 9 WE LOOKED AT BOTH
The recent uptrend in the stock markets and the U.S. dollar versus the Canadian dollar, and why they’re unlikely to mark the beginning of long term trends
AND
Canadian Clean Energy Income Trusts
Atlantic Power Corporation (OTC: ATPWF, TSX: ATP.UN), Energy Savings Income Fund (OTC: ESIUF, TSX: SIF.UN), Great Lakes Hydro Income Fund (OTC: GLHIF, TSX: GLH.UN), Innergex Power Income Fund (OTC: INRGF, TSX: IEF.UN), Macquarie Power & Infrastructure (OTC: MCQPF, TSX: MPT.UN), Northland Power Income Fund (OTC: NPIFF, TSX: NPI-U)
HERE IN PART 10, WE’LL EXAMINE:
Canadian Energy Infrastructure Income Funds
Altagas Income Trust (OTC: ATGFF, TSX: ALA.UN), InterPipeline (OTC: IPPLF, TSX: IPL.UN), Keyera Facilities (OTC: KEYUF, TSX: KEY.UN), Pembina Pipeline Fund (OTC: PMBIF, TSX: PIF.UN)
IN COMING PARTS WE’LL EXPLORE:
Canadian Utility Income Trusts
Bell Aliant (OTC: BLIAF, TSX: BA.UN)
Canadian Health Care Income Trust
CML Healthcare Inc. Fund (OTC: CMHIF, TSX: CLC.UN)
Canadian Real Estate Income Trusts
Canadian Apartment Properties REIT (OTC: CDPYF, TSX: CAR.UN), Northern Property REIT (OTC: NPRUF, TSX: NPR.UN), RIOCAN REIT: (OTC: RIOCF, TSX: REI.UN
Canadian Misc Business Trusts
Yellow Pages Income Fund (OTC: YLWPF, TSX: YLO.UN)
UNITED STATES
Communications
AT &T Inc (T), Verizon (VZ), Otelco (OTT), Windstream Corp (WIN)
Energy Infrastructure Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs)
Buckeye Partners (BPL), El Paso Pipeline Partners (EPB), Enterprise Products Partners (EPD), Energy Transfer Partners (ETP), Kinder Morgan Energy Partners (KMP), Magellan Midstream Partners (MMP), Nustar Energy (NS), ONEOK Partners (OKS), Sunoco Logistics Partners (SXL), TEPPCO Partners (TPP), Tortoise Energy Infrastructure Partners (TYG)
Coal MLPs
Alliance Resource Partners (ARLP), Northern Resource Partners (NRP), Penn Virginia Resources Partners (PVR)
Other MLPs
Terra Nitrogen Company, L.P. (TNH), StoneMor Partners (STON)
Utilities
Dominion Resources Inc. (D), Duke Energy Corp (DUK), Progress Energy (PGN), Southern Company (SO)
2. THE MARKET
See Part 10A. Here in 10B we get right to our examination of Canadian Energy Infrastructure Income Trusts.
3. CANADIAN ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INCOME TRUSTS - The Big Picture
A. Comparison to U.S. Energy Infrastructure Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs) – Similarities and Differences
See Part 10A for the full story. Here’s a summary of the key points
We will deal with these U.S. MLPs in depth in future articles. However, for now, here’s a list of our favorites:
· Buckeye Partners (BPL)
· El Paso Pipeline Partners (EPB)
· Enterprise Products Partners (EPD)
· Energy Transfer Partners (ETP)
· Kinder Morgan Energy Partners (KMP)
· Magellan Midstream Partners (MMP)
· Nustar Energy (NS) – also has an asphalt production arm that will benefit from both a shrinking number of suppliers and the Obama administration’s push for infrastructure projects like roads.
· ONEOK Partners (OKS)
· Sunoco Logistics Partners (SXL)
· TEPPCO Partners (TPP)
· Tortoise Energy Infrastructure Partners (TYG) – actually a fund that serves as a basket of these kinds of businesses
1. Similarities
Like the U.S. MLPs, these Canadian midstream (pipelines and storage) firms:
· Must distribute most of their available cash (90% for the U.S. MLPs in most cases) after that needed for maintenance and of current projects and new ones needed to maintain or grow revenues.
· Don’t pay tax at the entity level. Until Canadian tax law changes in 2011, those that don’t elect early conversion to corporations are not taxed at the entity level, allowing higher yields. While there is some uncertainty about how 2011 driven conversions to corporations will affect these trusts, the bottom line is that our selections’ distributions should not be significantly impaired due to various factors discussed below.
· Their revenues are generally based on capacity sold in advance to energy producers regardless of whether that oil or gas is actually moved through their pipelines or not.
2. Advantages
Thus like their U.S. counterparts, they offer reliable, high yields. However, they offer some intriguing advantages.
· Higher Yields: Their yields are generally a bit higher than the approximately 9% average of the U.S. MLPs.
· USD hedge: They all pay distributions in CAD (usually converted to USD by brokers in the U.S.), thus offering a USD hedge.
· Monthly distributions: Most pay each month, not quarterly like their U.S. counterparts.
3. Risks
· 2011 Canadian tax changes may adversely affect yield: Yes, the 2011 driven conversion to corporations with an additional layer of tax at entity level raises questions about how well each firm will be able to maintain its yield. As a group, energy infrastructure companies have relatively high depreciation expenses that can offset taxes.
Also, our specific picks are growing their businesses and can be expected to ultimately increase funds from operations and thus distributions to make up for funds lost to taxes. Note that most Canadian companies do not pay full theoretical taxes due to careful tax planning.
· Currency Risk: Distributions and share prices in CAD can be a dual edged sword. There will be periodic declines in the value of the CAD against the USD.
See Part 9A for full details on why we believe the CAD will appreciate over the coming years against the USD. In short, a more conservative, healthier banking and housing sector that did not indulge in subprime lending has meant that the CAD supply is not expanding on anything close to the scale of the USD. While that isn’t the only factor to consider, it’s a big one.
· Market Risk. Like virtually all shares, they will move with the overall market. Note that all of these are relatively thinly traded, and thus volatile, since little selling or buying can really move their share prices.
Remember: energy transport and storage is one of the most recession resistant industries. Thus these are great defensive plays that pay you very well while you wait for recovery.
4. ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INCOME TRUSTS– Specific Recommendations
As noted above, consider deferring further purchases until the current rally retests support.
NOTE:
CANADA CURRENTLY HAS A 15% WITHOLDING TAX FOR FOREIGN SHAREHOLDERS, WHICH CAN BE RECOVERED AS A TAX CREDIT BY SUBMITTING IRS FORM 1116 WITH YOUR TAX RETURN. IT’S AS YET UNCLEAR IF OR HOW THAT WILL CHANGE IN 2011.
ALL AMOUNTS QUOTED ARE IN U.S. DOLLARS (USD) UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED. ALL STOCK SYMBOLS ARE NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED (OTC = OVER THE COUNTER, TSX = TORONTO EXCHANGE). YIELDS ARE AS OF DAY BEFORE PUBLICATION.
A. AltaGas Income Trust (OTC: ATGFF, TSX: ALA.UN)
In addition to the usual combination of oil and gas extraction, gathering, transmission, and processing, this firm also has a green power generation division focused on wind and geothermal facilities, thus diversifying into another reliable and growing revenue source.
1. Advice
Buy under 12.15, Strong Buy under 1015. Yield over 17%.
Website: http://www.altagas.ca/
In addition to the usual combination of oil and gas extraction, gathering, transmission, and processing, this firm also has a green power generation division focused on wind and geothermal facilities, thus diversifying into another reliable and growing revenue source.
2. Why: Q4 Highlights include
· 15.4% increase in funds from operations (FFO)
· Continued expansion of wind and geothermal generation assets in power hungry Western Canada
· Successful renegotiated credit agreement supports our view that the firm has no credit access problems in a generally restrictive market, and puts the company in a position to make further strategic acquisitions at bargain prices
· Payout ratio remains a conservative 72%, adding security to the distribution
3. Concerns
Impact of 2011 tax increases
Both the high yield and low payout ratio provide significant cushion against higher taxes. Cut this by a third and you’re STILL getting around 12%.
Like all energy infrastructure firms, high depreciation expenses will protect a substantial portion of distributions from classification as taxable income to tax free return of capital.
12 month growth in outstanding shares is about 23%
We’d like this below 10%, and consider anything over 20% to be too dilutive. We’ll accept this for now, based on the solid overall results and understandable reluctance to increase debt.
4. Conclusion
With their excellent performance in a tough market and timely emphasis on gas and other high demand “green” energy sources, insiders have been buyers on the price dips. Me too.
B. Pembina Pipeline Income Fund (OTC: PMBIF, TSX: PIF.UN)
Owns and operates pipelines in the Alberta Tar Sands. While current energy prices have made tar sands oil unprofitable, that hasn’t slowed Pembina a bit. They get paid on a fixed rate of return basis, eliminating exposure to energy prices and even throughput declines.
1. Action
Buy under 12, Strong Buy under 10. Yield over 13%.
Website: http://www.pembina.com
2. Why
To get a quick feel for how healthy Pembina is, consider just the following two facts:
· The contracts are obviously long term, and the firm has affirmed that it will be able to at least sustain its current distribution through 2015, despite its plans to convert to a dividend paying corporation (thus taxed at entity level) sometime in 2010.
· They continue to expand capacity, adding Horizon Pipeline system in July 2008, and are investing CAD 165 million in the new Nipisi pipeline and CAD 260 million in the Mitsue pipeline.
· Debt has grown but remains quite manageable when compared to revenues and cash from operations shown in the below mentioned MD&A. Click on the link to see for yourself. Outstanding share growth over the past 12 months is around 1%. They have the cash they need.
· A quick review of the Management Analysis and Discussion (MD&A – see http://www.pembina.com/webcms.nsf/AllDoc/11E467568884F97B87257570000B9ED8/$File/2008MD&A.pdf ) essentially shows increases in everything you want to see grow: Net earnings, cash from operations, distributable and distributed cash, etc. Debt levels are quite manageable. Enterprise value declined, but that is based on share price and thus much more a reflection on the overall market than the firm itself.
3. Concerns
Payout ratio is about 95%. We would prefer this to be below 90%, but given the very steady fixed fee revenue stream, this is acceptable.
4. Conclusion
Pembina is another classic case of a great investment getting unjustly slammed over confusion about its revenue health. While current energy prices may make the tar sands oil unprofitable, that has no effect on Pembina’s financial health or distributions until at least 2015. Ditto its conversion to a corporation in 2010.
C. Inter Pipeline Fund (OTC: IPPLF, TSX: IPL/UN)
Created in 1997, Inter Pipeline Fund is a major petroleum transportation, storage and natural gas liquids extraction business based in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. Inter Pipeline is a publicly traded limited partnership (not a trust subject to 2011 tax changes) that owns and operates a diversified combination of energy infrastructure assets in western Canada, the United Kingdom, Germany and Ireland. This asset portfolio generates long-term and predictable cash flows, thereby providing unit holders with a growing and stable source of monthly cash distributions.
Note: As a Limited Partnership under the laws of Alberta, only Canadian residents can own units. Bummer for the rest of us, and thus vastly limited demand for shares that will limit price appreciation for Canadian residents.
1. Action
Buy under CAD 7.5, Strong Buy under 6.5. Yield about 13%.
Website: http://interpipelinefund.com/overview/index.html
Since this is only for Canadian investors, I’ll limit coverage to this brief mention and refer Canadians to the website for more info. Like the others above – steady revenues, great yield, plus exposure to the Euro as well as the CAD.
D. Keyera Facilities Income Fund (OTC: KEYUF, TSX: KEY.UN)
Keyera operates one of the largest natural gas midstream businesses in Canada. Its three business lines consist of:
· Natural gas gathering and processing
· Processing, transportation, and storage of natural gas liquids (NGLs) and crude oil
· Marketing of Natural Gas Liquids (NGLs) and sulphur. This gives them both added risk because this segment is exposed to prices for these commodities, and added reward when these prices are strong or their hedging strategies work well.
Keyera's gas processing plants and associated facilities are strategically located in the west central and foothills natural gas production areas of the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin. Keyera’s NGL infrastructure includes pipelines, terminals and processing and storage facilities in Edmonton and Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta, a major North American NGL hub. Keyera also markets propane, butane and condensate to customers across North America.
1. Action
Buy under 12.50, Strong Buy under 12. Yield over 14%.
Website: http://keyspancanada.com/titanweb/keyera/keyera.nsf/frmHome?openform
2. Why
In short, great results.
Record earnings and distributions, declining debt levels: For details, see highlights from the annual report: (http://keyspancanada.com/titanweb/keyera/keyera.nsf/AllDoc/132F8F32E5B7CBE587257567007788FA/$File/2008%20Q4%20final.pdf
Continued ability to obtain affordable financing: On April 14th 2009, the firm announced a long term senior unsecured debt private placement for CAD 97 million at 8.06% and will mature May 1, 2016. The funds will be used to repay CAD 90 million of existing long term debt when it matures on October 1 2009. In the words of CFO and VP Dean Setoguchi:
“Our ability to complete this transaction at favourable rates, given the current economic situation, is a testament to the strength of Keyera’s business model and conservative approach to our financial management”.
Continued expansion: Not surprisingly, Keyera’s ability to prosper and obtain funding in this environment has allowed them to acquire strategic growth assets at favorable prices. In December 2008 the firm acquired additional interests in three gas gathering and processing facilities in West Central Alberta.
Reliable distributions: Payout ratio is a very conservative 55%, share growth a conservative 10%. Except for the NLG by products sales, revenues are protected by capacity based contracts unaffected by oil prices or throughput. That is, customers contract on a long term basis to pay fixed fees to reserve a given volume of product to move through Keyera’s pipelines and storage facilities.
3. Concerns
Revenues can be adversely affected by declines in the NLG by products sales.
4. Conclusion
Even with risks from some exposure to the NLG by products prices, the high yield and ultra conservative payout ratio provide a large margin of safety. As energy prices recover, the NLG business will be a bonus.
5. Conclusion, Disclosure & More Info
Here in Part 10B presented specific recommendations of the best of the Canadian Energy Infrastructure Income Trusts.
In sum, they provide among the best risk/reward available for high dividend investors. They are similar in many ways to U.S. Energy Infrastructure MLPs, with the added advantage of generally higher yields and a valuable USD hedge. While the 2011 tax changes will cause these to convert to corporations, impact on the dividends of these specific recommendations should be minimal to none for at least the next number of years.
Part 10B will look at specific recommendations in this sector
Part 11 will deal with another superb Canadian income trust sector.
Disclosure: I have positions in most of the above mentioned investments.
Interested in learning more about investing in stocks that provide reliable high dividends with better transparency, appreciation potential, and liquidity than bonds? Visit http://highdividendstocksguide.blogspot.com
Nice blog :)
ReplyDeleteI saw you find BA.UN as a good investment. Good high dividend. I do not have BA.UN in my portfolio yet. I cannot wait to add it.